My stance on Mario canon (for versus debating)

-

The Mario series is very controversial when it comes to versus debating and power scaling, in no small part to its confusing canon. Now to a certain extent this is understandable, as there are so many games in the Mario franchise and not everyone is going to be knowledgeable in all or even most of them. However, I also feel that there is absolutely a double standard when it comes to the Mario series to write everything off as non-canon, while series with similar loose canons are not given the same treatment. Today I hope to reconcile some of that. This will intend to connect every part of the Mario franchise that I believe to be canon, with everything linking back to the mainline platformer Super Mario series.

Also, there is a certain idea that I have seen go around that I will call "not canon until proven otherwise". Now I don't necessarily have a problem with this argument, except that the Mario franchise seems to be the only series that this argument gets used against. For other series, I have seen plenty of people give the benefit of the doubt that "oh this piece of media isn't supported by canon, but it also doesn't contradict anything so it seems fine to use," which I also don't have an issue with this stance. In fact I have used this argument before. It is just that this argument seems to be flipped for the Mario franchise for no good reason, where suddenly everything is not canon until you can prove that it is canon. This is more of the double standard against the Mario series that I was talking about earlier.

Now despite that, I will be attempting to connect everything together through actual connections shown in the games and supporting material. So if you do subscribe to the above argument, then you should still come away with this understanding how everything connecting is canon.

Also if you're wondering about the Doofenshmirtz blog, that is unfortunately taking a little longer than expected, so in the meantime I am releasing this blog and potentially one more before Doof's. I have a list of characters that I would like to write about, so I can easily switch between several if I am feeling bored. Also in the future, I might write about specific matchup predictions for shows like Death Battle, so be on the lookout for those later.

With that stuff out of the way, let's begin diving into the canonicity of Mario.

Mainline Platformers

To start off, the games that everyone can agree are canon are the mainline series of platformers. These should be pretty obvious to anyone familiar with the series. The mainline games reference each other all the time and are sometimes direct sequels to each other, like the Super Mario Galaxy duology. When F.L.U.D.D. scans Mario at the beginning of Super Mario Sunshine, we can see clips of Super Mario Bros., Super Mario World, and Super Mario 64 in the bottom left corner, with the bottom right corner including the backwards names of all of those games, as well as Mario Bros., Super Mario Bros. 2, and Super Mario Bros. 3, among Mario Kart games we'll get into later. In Super Mario Odyssey, we again see clips from other games when Mario captures Bowser, with Super Mario Bros., Super Mario Bros. 3, Super Mario World, and Super Mario 64 being there. Obviously these aren't the only games in the Super Mario series, but it does show that they all exist canonical to each other if that wasn't already obvious.

A full list of games in the Super Mario series can be found here. This should also include any games closely tied to one or more of these games, such as Captain Toad Treasure Tracker, Super Mario Bros. 35, Super Mario World 2: Yoshi's Island, and Super Mario Land 3: Wario Land. These are either direct continuations of games in the Super Mario series or at least heavily tied to one of them.

This is probably where I should also talk about remakes. I covered this a little bit in my Yoshi blog, but I'll cover it here as well. Both the remakes of games and the original games should be valid for getting feats, arsenal, or otherwise from. In the Mario series specifically, this extra applies, as remakes will often make reference to the fact that they are the same story but a second time. Super Mario 64 DS specifically is another adventure that happens to have the same story, as Koopa the Quick referenced meeting Mario before in the DS version, while in the N64 version he has to introduce himself, indicating that they are two separate adventures in the same continuity.

This does include Super Mario Bros. 2, as even though the events of that game are claimed to be a dream, there is a lot of evidence to support them actually happening as well. The story from the instruction booklet implies that directly after waking up from their dream, Mario, Luigi, Peach, and Toad immediately went on an adventure mirroring the one from their dream, and the in-game story supports this too. Additionally, the Nintendo Player's Guide Mario Mania makes several references to the events of Super Mario Bros. 2 as if those events did canonically happen, so it should be treated as an actual adventure.

The Super Mario Maker games will be covered later. Now I think we have a pretty clear groundwork for the basis of canonicity for Mario, as all of the games here are undisputedly canon. If you are going to argue for any of these being non-canon, then at that point why have Mario characters in battles at all if they're only going to be a tiny fraction of their actual appearances. So these games will serve as a good collection of games that the other games will connect to.

Yoshi series

The Yoshi series is next, and this should probably be obvious to anyone familiar with the Yoshi series, but it is very closely tied with the Super Mario series. Now the Yoshi series is confirmed to not take place in the Mushroom Kingdom specifically, and instead takes place elsewhere, which makes sense as we see in Super Mario World that Yoshi's Island is separate from the Mushroom Kingdom. The Yoshi series is built off of Super Mario World 2: Yoshi's Island, which is obviously directly connected to Super Mario World. Moreover, the Perfect Ban Mario Character Daijiten, an old character encyclopedia for the Mario series, references that the Yoshi from Super Mario World is the same one that starred in three of his own games, those being Yoshi Cookie, Yoshi, and Yoshi's Safari, which were the three Yoshi games that were out at the time. 

In regards to specifically Yoshi's Wooly World and Yoshi's Crafted World, because I am sure people are confused about those because of their art style, they are confirmed by the developers to be a part of the same Yoshi world. Yoshi's Wooly World is featured in an official commercial detailing the history of Yoshi as a character, and is said in an interview that it was meant to fit into the Yoshi universe. Yoshi's Crafted World is the same way, where it was meant to fit into the Yoshi world, so they are canon to the rest of the Yoshi and Mario series.

Yes, the artstyle does play a factor into the gameplay and story of the game, but that shouldn't matter when talking about the Mario franchise, as the changes in artstyle are canonical in the series. For example, Super Mario Odyssey has a costume where Mario appears in his blocky appearance from Super Mario 64, and a Toad even references this and says he missed when Mario looked like this originally, calling it the good old days. This is supported by the Sunshine and Odyssey references I mentioned earlier, where boss fights from old games appear in-universe, retaining their old style, meaning the artstyle changes that happen to the world are canonical in-universe and not a point against Wooly World and Crafted World.

Mario Kart series

The next easiest to talk about is the Mario Kart series. This one is pretty straight-forward, Super Mario Kart and Mario Kart 64 are explicitly shown in F.L.U.D.D.'s heads-up display in Super Mario Sunshine, undisputedly connecting the Mario Kart series as canon. For further evidence, the sponsors that appear on the Mechanic Outfit in Super Mario Odyssey are some of the same sponsors from Mario Kart 8, setting the two series in the same universe. There's also some more evidence that'll be covered in the next section as it relates to both.

Additionally, the Mario Kart series being canon adds more evidence that the artstyle changes between games are canonical, as Mario and Donkey Kong Jr. have outfits in Mario Kart Tour where they appear as their 16-bit appearances from the original Super Mario Kart. 

Mario Sports series

This is for all of the Mario sports series, such as Mario Golf, Mario Tennis, Mario Baseball, Mario Strikers, and a few stand alone games. They are all together for simplicity-sake, and that there's no real reason some of them should be canon while others wouldn't be. Most of the evidence refers to "sports" in the general term anyway. Also some of these will also include more evidence for the Mario Kart series, as officially those are sometimes grouped together with the sports games.


Donkey Kong series

Next up is the Donkey Kong franchise of games. These include any game featuring Donkey Kong or one of the other kongs as the main characters, and I don't really feel the need to explain how all of these are connected to each other. The Donkey Kong series is obviously very closely-tied to the Mario franchise, given that they both started from the exact same game, but there is more connecting them than just that. 

The original Donkey Kong is obviously canon, due to the game being explicitly referenced as a past event in Super Mario Odyssey, and the original Donkey Kong connects to other Donkey Kong games thanks to being referenced by Cranky Kong many times throughout the series. He is stated to be the original Donkey Kong in the guidebook and this went all the way until Donkey Kong '94, where after that game he passed the Donkey Kong name onto the current DK. The manual for Mario Kart DS states that Donkey Kong creates music with his bongos, a very clear reference to Donkey Kong 64 and the Donkey Konga series, as that's the only time we've seen Donkey Kong use bongos. Mario Kart 7 features the track DK Jungle, which takes place on DK Island and has many of the same enemies, obstacles, and areas seen in Donkey Kong Country Returns. Overall there is a lot connecting the Donkey Kong series to other Mario games.

Luigi's Mansion series



Mario Maker series


Now as a group of level editor games, it may seem weird that they would be considered canon, but Super Mario Maker 2 has a story mode giving a reason for why Mario has to go through these levels. Additionally, characters from the level editor, such as Undodog and Mr. Eraser, appear as characters in the story mode, so it is clear that the level editor itself is canon to Mario Maker, and thus the rest of the Mario series.

Mario Party series


Wario series

The Wario franchise actually features several different series in it, but they are all connected all the same, so it will be easier to combine them to talk about. To prove that the WarioWare and Wario Land series are connected to each other first of all, the intro to Wario's story in WarioWare Twisted features the Music Box from Wario Land 3 and a picture of the Golden Pyramid from Wario Land 4.

To connect them to other Mario series now, obviously the rest of Wario Land is connected to the first Wario Land game, which itself was a sequel to Super Mario Land 2, a mainline platformer game. Furthermore, the guide for Mario Kart Wii states that Wario started a Gold Mine because of all of the treasure he got from both hunting exploitations and minigames, referencing both the Wario Land and WarioWare series. The Wario Car from Wario Land 4 appears in Mario Kart: Double Dash and the Mario Kart Arcade series, and the Wario Bike from WarioWare appears in Mario Kart Wii. Diamond City from the WarioWare series is also a track in Mario Kart Arcade GP.

Mario & Luigi series

The Mario & Luigi series has five games, as well as two remakes. The most obvious reference to other series is Superstar Saga directly calling Super Mario Bros., Super Mario World, and Super Mario 64 past adventures. The official magazine for Partners in Time also references many adventures Mario and Luigi have gone on, stating to have won karting tournaments (Mario Kart), become tennis stars (Mario Tennis), danced their way to justice (DDR: Mario Mix), hit the golfing greens (Mario Golf), and one of them has been to space (Super Mario Land 2). It also states that Luigi has proved what a great ghostbuster he is, in reference to Luigi's Mansion, and in Dream Team, Luigi's Dream Deep also references Luigi's Mansion with Luigi stating that he hunts ghosts. Toadette references Captain Toad Treasure Tracker in Paper Jam. Mario and Luigi's house in the Superstar Saga remake features a trophy from Mario Kart 8, tennis rackets and golf clubs lifted straight out of the sports games, and Builder Mario's outfit from Mario Maker.

Mario + Rabbids series

Perhaps my second most controversial inclusion for canon, the Mario + Rabbids duology of games, while a crossover series, does not contradict the Mario series in any meaningful way. The Phantom, in his song, references both Donkey Kong and Mario Kart as canon games that this Mario experienced, establishing that the Mario from this game is the same one as the one from those games. Beep-0 asks Yoshi about Yoshi's Island, and the Croaker Disposer weapon, based on Winky from Donkey Kong Country, references Monkey Mines from that game as an actual location. Rosalina also states that she went looking for her family once, a clear reference to her backstory from Super Mario Galaxy.

Now yes, it is a crossover game, but unlike other crossover games these actually provide a reason for how the two worlds combined. With the vortex at the beginning of the first game sucking everything from the Mario universe in to it. Additionally, we cannot really say that these Rabbids are the exact same Rabbids from other Rabbid or Rayman games, unlike what we can do for the Mario characters, so there is no trouble with scaling as it isn't actually crossover scaling. Again, nothing actually contradicts these games being canon, and there is more evidence in favor of it being canon than against it.

Paper Mario series

Oh boy, the Paper Mario series. There have been a lot of discussions about the canonicity of the Paper Mario series, many arguments started and even several wars between neighboring countries about this. Not actually but the point stands that this is pretty controversial, so I will be going very in depth on this one, thoroughly explaining my points and debunking any counterarguments I have seen.

First off, Paper Mario was originally intended to be a sequel to Super Mario RPG, and in Japan is known as Mario Story, only becoming Paper Mario after localization. Goombario in Paper Mario states that Mario from that game is the same one as the one in Super Mario Bros. Mario & Luigi Superstar Saga directly calls Paper Mario a past adventure of Mario's. The Rainbow Road from Mario Kart: Super Circuit features the Bowser's Castle from Paper Mario in the background. Huey from Paper Mario Color Splash says that images from Super Mario Bros. 3 are from the ancient past, and Huey later states that Mario has been fighting Bowser for 30 years, an out of universe reference to this game coming out on the 30th anniversary of Super Mario Bros., as Mario's age is 24 or 25 and would not make sense if this Mario was not the same one from that game.

Bowser's Castle in Paper Mario the Origami King has several images of Bowser in 3D despite being a Paper Mario game. Colored Pencils from Origami King says Mario was better as a sidescroller, and while it technically could be a reference to Super Paper Mario, it is highly unlikely and is instead most likely referring to the mainline platformer games. The box for Paper Mario: The Thousand Year Door states that Mario is returning to paper form, and given the context of the sentence it is clearly talking about Mario as a character. The official magazine for Partners in Time says that Mario and Luigi are going back in time to before they were paper, clearly referring to them as the same Mario and Luigi as the ones in the Paper Mario series.

There are several examples of Mario transforming into his 8-bit self from Super Mario Bros., as that happens in Paper Mario, Thousand Year Door, and Super Paper Mario. From an in-universe standpoint, this makes no sense if the Mario from those games is not the same as the one from Super Mario Bros. Super Paper Mario's Pal Pill also summons a bunch of 8-bit Mario's. Additionally, Luigi's Diary from Paper Mario makes very clear references to Mario Golf, Tennis, and Party.

As seen, there is a lot of evidence pointing in favor of the Paper Mario series being canon to the rest of the games. However, I know that people are hesitant to say that the Paper Mario series is canon for two main reasons: Paper Jam, and the Paper artstyle. I'll cover these one at a time.

To start, Mario & Luigi: Paper Jam appears to be a crossover between the Mario & Luigi and Paper Mario series. However, Paper Jam has very few actual references to previous Paper Mario games, and those are only Tower Power Pokey and Sombrero Guy appearing. These actually come with their own set of issues, notably that Tower Power Pokey has the Royal Sticker from Paper Mario: Sticker Star. This is actually impossible given what we know about the Royal Stickers. If Paper Jam takes place after Sticker Star, then the Pokey shouldn't have the Royal Sticker. This is because the Royal Sticker is only there because of the Sticker Festival, which happens once every year, going wrong and Bowser sending the Royal Stickers across the Mushroom Kingdom. And at the end of the game, Mario makes a wish to make the Sticker Festival no longer be ruined, meaning the Tower Power Pokey couldn't have gotten it after the game.

However, Paper Jam also can't take place before Sticker Star, because otherwise Tower Power Pokey wouldn't have the Royal Sticker as they were released at the beginning of the game. So Paper Jam must take place during Sticker Star's events, right? Well, no because there's no point in Sticker Star's story that a giant break in the action could take place. As well, Kertsi was with Mario the entire time during the events of Sticker Star, yet she isn't referenced at all in Paper Jam. Bowser was corrupted by the Royal Sticker directly after the Royal Stickers spread across the world, and doesn't get uncorrupted until the very end of the game, yet we can clearly see in Paper Jam that Paper Bowser is not corrupted by the Royal Sticker. Therefore, there is no point in time within the story of Paper Mario: Sticker Star where Paper Jam could take place, confirming that the Paper Mario from Paper Jam is not the same character as the Mario from the Paper Mario games.

To further back this up, there is a room in Paper Mario: The Origami King with pictures of Peach from every Paper Mario adventure. We see Paper Mario, The Thousand-Year Door, Super Paper Mario, Sticker Star, Color Splash, and Origami King, yet Paper Jam is missing. If the Paper Mario characters seen in Paper Jam were truly the same characters as seen in the Paper Mario series, we should expect to see a picture of Paper Peach here, but we do not, meaning that the characters are different.

Based off of this, and the fact that there is a ton of evidence in favor of Paper Mario being canon to the series, originating both before and after Paper Jam's release, even by the creators of Paper Jam, it is clear that the Paper universe seen in Paper Jam is not the same as the Mario universe seen in the Paper Mario games. Paper Jam does not reference the Paper Mario series in any meaningful way and is actively contradicted by 2 separate Paper Mario games.

Now onto the second point against Paper Mario being canon, and that is the Paper artstyle. First off, as mentioned earlier, the changing artstyle is a canonical event in the Mario series. Evidence can be found under the Mainline Platformers and Mario Kart series sections, but there is a few more. Super Mario Odyssey features several sections that involve Mario turning into his 8-bit form from Super Mario Bros, and 1-1 of Super Mario Bros. is even an in-universe movie. Super Mario RPG also features Mario turning into his 8-bit form from Super Mario Bros. so it isn't a problem. Yes, the paper artstyle does factor into the gameplay in several sections, but this shouldn't matter either, as both Yoshi's Wooly World and Yoshi's Crafted World have artstyles that play huge roles in their gameplay too, and yet they were confirmed to take place in the Yoshi world by the developers as mentioned earlier. So the same can easily be said for Paper Mario.

Yes, characters can get crumpled up and folded, but realistically that isn't too far from what happens in the rest of the Mario franchise either. Mario can be squished completely flat by a hammer, or rolled up into a ball, and Luigi can straight up be turned into a surfboard. Many characters can be turned directly into pinballs, and Donkey Kong can do something similar to enemies. Additionally, every character in Mario Kart can survive and recover from getting squished completely flat. The level of body distortion in the Paper Mario series isn't far from what the other series's have shown us, so this isn't a valid argument.

I do not want this section to go on longer than it has to, so here is the conclusion. The Paper Mario series has too much evidence in favor of it being canon to be ignored. Paper Jam has too many contradictions with the Paper Mario series and makes no effort to present itself as the Paper Mario series, so should not be used as a counterargument. The artstyle changes in the series are no different than anything else that happens in the rest of the Mario franchise. Paper Mario is undoubtably canon.

Super Mario Adventure comics

Unlike all of the previous examples, the Super Mario Adventures comics do not have anything specific I can point to that would show that they are canon. However, unlike the rest of non-video game Mario media, these comics stay consistent with the game, and in fact introduces several things that would become staples of the Mario series in the future, such as Luigi being scared of ghosts, Peach's willingness to fight back, and Bowser showing romantic interest in Peach, all of which were shown later on in the games. It also shows several scenes that must have happened in the game canon that we're never shown in the games, such as Mario and Luigi reacquainting with Yoshi as adults. 

While there is nothing that explicitly says that these comics are canon, they remain very consistent with the games and there is nothing that would suggest that they are not canon. 

Miscellaneous Games


There are other games that should be considered canon too, but they don't have enough material to give them their own section.

I will continue to update this section or any other sections in the future if more information comes out for any of these.

So that should give you a good idea of how everything fits into the Mario canon. Everything that is not listed here, such as any of the cartoons, Hotel Mario, Mario & Sonic, Super Smash Bros., Mario-Kun, or any of the three movies should not be considered canon. They contradict the games too much to be canon and some of them are explicitly stated to be not canon. I hope you enjoyed this blog and feel free to ask any questions you may have. Next blog should be another character analysis (probably another Mario character), and then Doofenshmirtz will come after that. See y'all next time!

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

How Powerful is Bowser?

-
Image
  Before we start: For what is being considered canon to the Mario series, see my previous blog . This includes my reasoning for considering what I am for this, including Paper Mario, Mario + Rabbids, and the Super Mario Adventures comic. I will also be using any official guides, manuals, websites, or any other official source, and while the original Japanese will have the most priority, I will be including any official translations as long as they do not deviate too far from the original source and are used as supplemental material. In terms of what will be listed as arsenal, Bowser has had access to several powerful artifacts, and these will be viewed on a case-by-case basis. In general, I won't be listing anything that isn't reasonable for Bowser to still be in possession of, which includes several one-off macguffins such as the Star Rod, the Dream Stone, Music Keys, the Vibe Scepter, the Royal Sticker, or the Pure Hearts. Anything else realistic is fair game. You could tech...
Read more

VS Character Analysis: Dr. Doofenshmirtz (Part 1)

-
Image
Before I begin: Ah jeez Phineas and Ferb canon is a nightmare. This will be covering nearly all official material featuring Doofenshmirtz. The tv shows and movies will hold precedence over all else, but almost everything will be looked at. This includes Phineas and Ferb, both movies, Milo Murphy’s Law, Hamster & Gretel, any official commercials, all Phineas and Ferb video games, all books*, Spot the Diff, Shark Tank, Doofenshmirtz’s Daily Dirt, Take Two with Phineas and Ferb**, Random Rings, Character Commentaries, Theme Song Take Over, How NOT To Draw Dr. Doofenshmirtz, the 2010 Osborne Family Spectacle of Dancing Lights, and The Best Live Tour Ever. In general, these all do not contradict the show much, and the ways that they do can easily be explained and are relatively minor (For example, several novels and magazines claim Baljeet's last name is "Rai", while the show has it as "Tjinder". Both were officially given by co-creator Jeff "Swampy" Ma...
Read more